Let Tall Guy Make Cater You Thanksgiving Dinner

Pecan Pie

We’re dedicated to making Thanksgiving dinner easier on you with our order-in, made from scratch, locally-sourced Tall Guy Menu.  Whether you’re hosting a festive gathering or need an impressive dish to pass, we offer traditional favorites that you can pre-order today thru Friday, November 18th.

The Main Course

turkey and stuffing

In addition to Tall Guy’s all natural, boneless Turkey Breast dressed with butter, fresh rosemary, salt and pepper, and scratch made Turkey Gravy or Vegetarian Mushroom Gravy, our main course menu also includes: Roasted Pork or Beef Tenderloin, Hickory Smoked Ham, and Cranberry Orange Relish.

Side Dishes

Herb Roasted Butternut Squash

As for our Thanksgiving Side Dishes, enjoy new menu items, like: Herb Roasted Butternut Squash, Sweet Potato Casserole with Treat Bake Shop Candied Pecan Streusel, a Butternut Squash Soup made with locally sourced apples, fresh sage, with a hint of Wisconsin maple syrup, and Wild Rice with leeks, mushrooms, and sweet currants.

Wild Rice with leeks, mushrooms, and sweet currants

Of course we still offer our highly requested classics, like Green Bean Casserole, made with house made mushroom soup, fried onion strings, and sourdough breads crumbs, and Califlower Gratin, a healthier, creamier rendition of potato gratin made with Nueske’s apple smoked bacon, melted gruyere and Parmesan, and crusted bread crumbs.

potato gratin

All side dishes and salads are served in a half-size pan, serving up to 8-10 people.  However, if you’re anticipating an extra hungry crowd (or, you just want those delicious Thanksgiving leftovers for lunch on Friday!) we’re happy to help you estimate appropriate quantities.  All of our Thanksgiving dishes come fully prepared and refrigerated with heating instructions.

Appetizers & Dessert

Bourbon BBQ Meatballs

Don’t for get about our Passed Appetizers, like fruit, veggie, and cheese & sausage platters, Rumaki, award-winning Bourbon BBQ Meatballs, and Miller Baking Company Pretzel Bites served with Sprecher Rootbeer Mustard.  An absolute-must-order is Mrs. Tall Guy’s Salted Caramel Chocolate Pecan Pie with a big spoonful of Purple Door Ice Cream.  It is heavenly! Thanksgiving Salted Caramel Chocolate Pecan Pie

Place Your Order(s)

So we can help you have the best Thanksgiving feast to date (with little to no mess or stress), please place your Thanksgiving order by Friday, November 18th, at 5:00pm.  Orders may be picked up on Wednesday, November 23rd, from 1:00-7:00 p.m.  Click HERE to place your order(s).