Tall Guy’s Top Wedding Menus in 2015

Grilled Goodness Wedding

If you know Milwaukee, you know that this eclectic city offers some of the hippest, most fabulous wedding venues – and we’ve seen it all first-hand working with dozens of lovebirds to customize their wedding menus.   We take-to-heart the personal style and wishes of the bride & groom when we cater weddings.   In some cases, we’ve added the groom’s home brew to our mac & cheese or used Anodyne Coffee as rub for our Tall Guy sliders.

Whatever the touch, it’s been a delicious, creative year, and I’d like to share Tall Guy’s top wedding menus from 2015:

Garden Wedding @ Sangerhouse

Sanger House pot and fountainPhoto By: Artists’ Eye Photography

Aside from master landscaping, this cream city historic home – located in Brewer’s Hill – has a great vibe and provides intimacy for your private party.  This past summer, Bobby & MaLisa,  wanted colorful, locally-sourced goodness to serve to their guests – so here’s what we did…

Sanger House MealsGarden Wedding Menu

  • Clock Shadow Creamery cheeses, Potter’s crackers, assorted fresh veggies
  • Roasted red pepper hummus
  • Fresh fruit display and balsamic house salad
  • Char grilled chicken breast with Tall Guy Bourbon BBQ sauce and pineapple salsa
  • Grilled flank steak with roasted tomato butter
  • Oven roasted veggies

Breakfast-for-Dinner @ Anodyne Coffee

Anodyne with logo

​In my opinion, Nicole & Peter started their lives out right together with a laid-back, Wisconsin style, breakfast-for-dinner menu.  Everything about their wedding buffet was full of sweet & savory yum.  Anodyne, located in Walker’s Point, is a hip, bright space, set with a stage for local musicians.

Anodyne Breakfast

Breakfast-for-Dinner Menu

  • Bloody Mary shooters with cracked black pepper & Nueske bacon
  • Chicken and waffles with bourbon maple syrup
  • Breakfast potatoes with fresh herbs
  • Assorted mini quiches
  • Fruit Skewers with spice rub and rum glaze
  • Bacon – lots of bacon!

Elegant Picnic @ Urban Ecology Center

Urban EcologyPhoto By: UEC Wedding Photographer

When you step inside The UEC at Riverside, it feels like you’re doing the world a favor.  This venue – which has a rustic, open design – is all about community and taking care of our planet.  And, I like that.  I also really enjoyed catering this elegant picnic menu for earth-friendly Becky & Adam.

Urgan Ecology MealElegant Picnic Menu

  • Caprese Skewers
  • Panko crusted mac & cheese bites w/ garlic aioli or marinara
  • Char grilled Tuscun lettuce salad with fennel, red bell pepper, shredded carrots, crumbled gorgonzola, balsamic dressing
  • Choice of slider on a pretzel bun: bourbon bbq meatball with Carolina slaw, vegan black bean and mushroom, or turkey stuffed with crumbled feta and sautéed spinach
  • Twice baked potato wedges
  • Fruit Skewers
  • Roasted asparagus spears

Grilled Goodness @ South Shore Pavilion

South ShorePhoto By: TJ Uttke Photography

Sarah & Neil hosted a beautiful summer party for their guests at South Shore Pavilion in Bay View, located on Lake Michigan.   In addition to serving-up our grilled menu, they invited us to provide bar services – which we love to do.

Southshore Meal

Grilled Goodness Menu

  • Char grilled Tuscan salad
  • Flank steak with roasted tomato butter
  • Mouth-watering asparagus
  • Mini bourbon pork meatballs
  • Harvest salad

Dr. Who Theme @ The Rustic Manor

Rustic ManorPhoto By: Shanon Z Photography

Aaron & Sam put on a show with a “Dr. Who” themed wedding – which, I have to give them props – it was a lot of fun.  For their menu, we spiced up our classic dishes and got great reviews.

Rustic Manor Meal

Dr. Who Menu

  • Spicy panko breaded mac & cheese bites
  • Bourbon bbq pork meatballs
  • Rumaki with balsamic glaze (bacon wrapped cream cheese filled dates)
  • Scratch made garlic mashed potato bar
  • Super fruit salad
  • Crumbled goat cheese, walnuts, and organic spring mix with vinaigrette
  • Char grilled chicken breast with tomatillo salsa
  • Ratatouille veggie mix
  • Roasted asparagus


If you’re looking to stay in the loop with wedding trends, our local friends Married in Milwaukee make for a fantastic resource.  There is also time to attend WEDMKE – the newest, coolest wedding showcase in the city, to be held on March 13th at Turner Hall Ballrooms.  Tall Guy will be amongst one of 50 vendors, excited to get you ready for your big day.

Front Room Turner HallPhoto By: Front Room Photography

Simply put, Tall Guy and A Grill has great local connections, takes pride in being pros behind-the-scenes, and makes sure your customized experience is – all around – amazing.

Tall_Guy_Wedding_Servers“My son and his new bride used your services this past Friday for their wedding.  On a scale of 1 to 10, I give you 10’s!  The food was outstanding and plentiful.  Many thanks for making there day extra special.” – Joe Bloechl