Party Catering Menu Drop off

Party Catering Menu | Drop Off

Drop Off means your party catering is a low profile drop off delivery. If you are looking for something with more support and staff please head to our Party Full Service Menu. Feel free to ask about our vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free menu options.

start

Choose from a mix of hot, cold, or trayed appetizers to get the party started

12” platter will serve up to 15 guests | 16” platter will serve up to 25 guests

hot

minimum order 2 dozen
pieces for each hot item

Mini Bourbon BBQ
Pork Meatballs

ground pork, house
breadcrumbs, Tall Guy
Bourbon BBQ Sauce
$15.99/dozen

Mini Pretzel Bite &
Brat Skewer with
Sprecher Root Beer
Mustard

Wisconsin brat and pretzel
bites, bamboo skewer,
mustard dipping sauce
$15.99/dozen

Rumaki

dates stuffed with cream
cheese, wrapped in Nueske’s
bacon
$15.99/dozen

Arancini Bites

cheesy herbed risotto, panko
crusted and fried
$15.99/dozen

Wisconsin Napoleon

Carr Valley bread cheese,
char grilled Wisconsin
smoked sausage, potato,
mustard vinaigrette, bamboo
skewer
$17.99/dozen

cold

minimum order 2 dozen
pieces for each cold item

Elote Tartlet

Alsum Farm sweet corn,
queso fresco, mayo, spiced
lime vinaigrette, micro
cilantro, savory tart shell
$16.99/dozen

Grilled Peach Skewer

char grilled peach, fresh
mozzarella, basil, Oro di
Oliva peach balsamic glaze,
bamboo skewer
$16.99/dozen

Creole Shrimp
Skewers

Cajun seasoned shrimp on
bamboo skewers, spicy house
remoulade
$20.99/dozen

Caprese Skewer

fresh mozzarella, cherry
tomatoes, and basil on
bamboo skewers with
balsamic glaze
$15.99/dozen

Fruit Skewers

trio of seasonal fruit on
knotted bamboo picks, glazed
with rum, lime juice, brown
sugar, and honey. can be
customized with your favorite
fruits upon request
$16.99/dozen

Pretzel Bites & Dips

Miller Baking Company
Pretzel bites with Sprecher
Root Beer Mustard, Mustard
Girl Stone Ground Deli
mustard, roasted red pepper
hummus, and Tall Guy
Pretzel dip.
Large Bowl (feeds 20 people)
$54.99

Chips & Guacamole

large bowl of house fried red
corn tortilla chips, 1 pint each
of tomato salsa and elote
(corn relish), and 1 quart of
fresh guacamole.
Large Bowl (feeds 15 people)
$59.99

Bar Snacks

large bowl of house lattice cut
potato chips, one pint of Tall
Guy chip dip, half pint of
house made pickles, small
bowl of smoky pretzels with
local mustard, one pint of
artisan nut mixture.
(feeds 20 people) $64.99

box lunch $11.99/p

Wraps and sandwiches include house fried lattice cut potato chips, seasonal fruit side, and fresh baked cookie. Salads include pretzel roll, butter, fresh baked cookie, and dressing on the side

Remember to place your order at least 48 hours in advance!

Box Lunch has same menu items as Cold Buffet below

cold buffet $12.99/p

Minimum order is 10 box lunches which can consist of up to 3 different choices.

Orders greater than 20 can include up to 5 different box choices.

To guarantee your selections, please place your order at least 48 hours in advance.

Since we prepare our food fresh to order, ability to fill last minute requests is limited.

Add sliced char-grilled chicken to any salad for $3

Add Creole shrimp to any salad for $4

sandwich/
wrap

Italian Sandwich

smoked ham, Genoa salami,
pepperoni, fresh smoked
mozzarella, mayo, Full Belly
giardiniera, greens, and black
olive tapenade on ciabatta
bread

Smoked Ham &
Cheese Sandwich

smoked ham, Martha’s
Pimento Cheese, sliced green
apples, and greens on ciabatta
bread

Roast Beef Sandwich

fresh sliced roast beef,
crumbled Gorgonzola,
balsamic caramelized onions,
peppercorn horseradish sauce,
and greens on ciabatta bread

5 Lillies Turkey Wrap

all-natural peppered turkey
breast, Full Belly giardiniera,
5 Lilies seasonal jam, pickled
red onion, greens, and sharp
white cheddar cheese on a
whole wheat wrap

Turkey Bacon Wrap

all-natural peppered turkey
breast, sharp white cheddar,
crumbled Nueske’s Bacon,
tomato, greens, ranch dressing,
whole wheat wrap

Chicken Salad Wrap

char grilled chicken breast,
celery, dates, walnuts, greens,
and SA Braai chutney cream
cheese spread on a whole
wheat wrap

Pesto Chicken Wrap

house basil pesto (nut free),
char grilled chicken breast,
shaved parmesan, tomato,
greens, whole wheat wrap

Chicken Caesar Wrap

char grilled chicken breast,
house Caesar dressing, shaved
parmesan, tomato, greens,
whole wheat wrap

Veggie Hummus Wrap

roasted red pepper hummus
spiced with artisan sriracha
from The Brinery, cucumbers,
carrots, sliced bell peppers, and
black olive tapenade on a
whole wheat wrap

Portabella Wrap

balsamic marinated and grilled
portabella mushroom, sliced
bell peppers, crumbled goat
cheese, greens, roasted red
pepper sauce

salads

Garden

heritage greens with petite

green and red leaf lettuce,

cherry tomatoes, carrots,

cucumber, house croutons,

balsamic vinaigrette

Wisconsin Wedge

butter lettuce, Nueske’s

bacon, tomato, crumbled bleu,

Treat Bake Shop candied

pecans, creamy peppercorn

dressing

Caesar Salad

romaine, parmesan cheese,

house crouton, lemon wedge,

house Caesar dressing

Apple Bleu

heritage greens with petite

green and red leaf lettuce,

apple, crumbled bleu cheese,

Treat Bake Shop candied

pecans, dried cranberries,

champagne vinaigrette

Spring/Summer

Panzanella

arugula, red onion, cucumber,

tomato, basil, shaved

parmesan, fresh baked bread,

creamy peppercorn dressing

(available in

Spring/Summer)

Superfruit

heritage greens with petite

green and red leaf lettuce,

strawberries, blueberries,

crumbled goat cheese,

walnuts, balsamic vinaigrette

(available in

Spring/Summer)

Peach

pea tendril greens, char grilled

peaches, burrata, Treat Bake

Shop spiced almonds, peach

balsamic dressing

(available in

Spring/Summer)

Strawberry

sunflower shoot greens,

strawberries, Treat Bake Shop

candied pecans, balsamic

bellavitano cheese,

champagne vinaigrette

(available in

Spring/Summer)

Fall/Winter

Panzanella

kale greens blend, shaved

brussels sprouts, cornbread,

butternut squash, fresh herbs,

creamy peppercorn dressing

(available in Fall/Winter)

Winter Greens

kale greens blend, green

apple, shaved brussels

sprouts, carrots, pomegranate,

balsamic bellavitano cheese,

champagne vinaigrette

(available in Fall/Winter)

hot buffet

From tacos to bbq to Italian, you covered. Includes earth friendly disposable place setting and serving utensils. Minimum order for any hot buffet is 10 people.

We are happy to accommodate any dietary restrictions or customize any of our menu items to meet your needs. To guarantee your selections, place your order at least 48 hours in advance. Because we prepare our meals fresh-to-order, our ability to fill last-minute.

taco bar

$14.99/person
one of the hottest food trends
on the market this year.
includes corn and flour
tortillas, tomato salsa, peach
salsa, queso fresco, sour
cream, house made
guacamole, seasonal green
salad, house fried corn tortilla
chips, and fresh baked
cookies.

Choose 2 of the following to
complete your taco bar:

sliced beef brisket
shrimp (add $2/person)
flank steak (add $2/person)
sliced chicken
smoky pulled pork
sliced portabella with sautéed
onions and peppers
(vegetarian)
pulled bbq jackfruit (vegan)

add Mexican rice with
cilantro lime black beans
for an additional
$2.50/person

additional protein options
can be added for $3/person

bbq buffet

$15.99/person
includes fresh baked
cornbread and honey butter,
Carolina slaw, seasonal green
salad, and fresh baked
cookies.

Choose 2 of the following to
complete your bbq buffet:

smoky pulled pork
sliced brisket (available
smoked or oven roasted)
pulled chicken
baby back ribs (add
$3/person)
pulled bbq jack fruit (vegan)

mediterranean
buffet

$14.99/person
includes char-grilled chicken
breast topped with
Mediterranean relish (olive
blend, crumbled feta,
tomatoes), roasted red
potatoes, charred green beans
(fresh green beans, topped
with smoked gremolata –
parsley, lemon zest, garlic),
seasonal green salad with
dressing on the side, rolls and
butter, and assorted fresh
baked cookies.

italian buffet

$15.99/person
includes Mama Mucci’s fresh
garlic and parsley linguine,
house marinara sauce, smoked
mozzarella alfredo, Grandma
Betty’s beef meatballs, sliced
grilled chicken, Caesar salad,
garlic bread, and fresh baked
cookies.

mardi gras
buffet

$15.99/person
a taste of New Orleans.
includes red beans and rice,
Cajun braised chicken pan
sauce, seasonal green salad,
apple cider braised collard
greens with Nueske’s bacon,
cheddar biscuits, and fresh
baked cookies.

chili bar

$14.99/person
house made meat chili and
black bean veggie chili served
with pickled red onions, fresh
limes, queso fresco, sour
cream, elbow mac, fresh fried
corn tortilla strips, cornbread
with honey butter, and house
baked cookies.

slider buffet

$15.99/person
includes house fried potato
chips, seasonal green salad,
fresh baked cookies, Miller
Baking Company pretzel
slider rolls, and condiments.
rolls and condiments are
packaged separately so guests
can build their own custom
sliders.

Choose 2 of the following
entrees to complete your
slider buffet:

bourbon bbq pork meatball
with Carolina slaw

pulled bbq chicken

smoked pulled pork

sliced beef brisket

cheddar stuffed grass fed beef

bacon, bleu, and garlic stuffed
grass fed beef

ground turkey, feta, and
spinach

maple glazed pork belly with
pickled red onions

mini brats with kraut

vegan black bean

portabella mushroom with
spinach and roasted red
pepper sauce (vegan)

additional protein options
can be added for $3/person

Choose 1 of the following
sides to complete your slider
buffet:

Fruit Skewers
trio of seasonal fruit on
knotted bamboo picks, glazed
with rum, lime juice, brown
sugar, and honey. can be
customized with your favorite
fruits upon request

Tall Guy Pasta
tri-color rotini, Wisconsin
cheese curds, diced bell
pepper, sliced black olives,
cherry tomatoes, house Italian
vinaigrette

Carolina Slaw
shredded cabbage and carrots,
dressed with apple cider
vinegar and Dijon mustard
Southern style dressing
Fingerling Potato
crumbled Nueske’s bacon,
egg, fresh green beans, diced
celery, fresh herbs, fingerling
potatoes, house vinaigrette

New Potato
jalapeno Caesar dressing,
diced tomato, shaved brussels
sprouts

Southwest Corn
Alsum farm sweet corn, black
beans, green onion, shaved
radish, fresh herbs, lime
vinaigrette

Caprese Pasta
fresh mozzarella cheese, basil,
sliced cherry tomatoes, penne
pasta, house Italian
vinaigrette

a la carte

Half pan size feeds 8-10 guests | Full pan size feeds 20-25 guests | Small Bowl feeds 10 people | Medium Bowl feeds 20 people | Large Bowl feeds | 30 people

tall guy
favorites

Baked Mostaccioli

four cheese blend, house
marinara, fresh Italian herbs,
roasted red pepper flakes.
Half Pan $29.99
Full Pan $49.99

Wisconsin Grass Fed
Beef Lasagna

Wisconsin sourced grass fed
beef, fresh lasagna noodles,
four cheese blend, ricotta,
house marinara
Half Pan $44.99
Full Pan $79.99

Vegetable Lasagna

seasonal sautéed vegetables,
ricotta cheese, fresh lasagna
noodles, and smoked
mozzarella cream sauce.
Half Pan $36.99
Full Pan $69.99

sliders

$36/dozen

These quarter pound sliders
come 12 to an order and
include rolls, sliders, and
condiments packaged
separately.

Bourbon BBQ Pork Meatball
with Carolina Slaw

Pulled BBQ Chicken

Smoked Pulled Pork

Sliced Beef Brisket

Cheddar Stuffed Grass Fed
Beef

Bacon, Bleu, and Garlic
stuffed Grass Fed Beef

Ground Turkey, Feta, and
Spinach

Maple Glazed Pork Belly
with Pickled Red Onions

Mini Brats with Kraut

Vegan Black Bean

Portabella Mushroom with
Spinach and Roasted Red
Pepper Sauce

picnic

All items here are available in
small, medium, and large
sizes.

Small Bowl $29.99
Medium Bowl $44.99
Large Bowl $59.99

Tall Guy Pasta
tri-color rotini, Wisconsin
cheese curds, diced bell pepper,
sliced black olives, cherry
tomatoes, house Italian
vinaigrette

Caprese
fresh mozzarella cheese, basil,
sliced cherry tomatoes, penne
pasta, house Italian vinaigrette
Fingerling Potato
crumbled Neuske bacon, egg,
fresh green beans, diced celery,
fresh herbs, fingerling potatoes,
house vinaigrette

New Potato
jalapeno Caesar dressing, diced
tomato, shaved brussels sprouts
Southwest Corn
Alsum farm sweet corn, black
beans, green onion, shaved
radish, fresh herbs, lime
vinaigrette

Carolina Slaw*
shredded cabbage and carrots,
dressed with apple cider
vinegar and Dijon mustard
Southern style dressing
Slaw is available for

$19.99/small bowl
$29.99/medium bowl
$39.99/large bowl

salads

All items are available in
small, medium, and large
sizes.

Half Pan (feeds 10) $29.99
Full Pan (feeds 20) $44.99
Large Pan (feeds 30) $54.99

Garden

heritage greens with petite
green and red leaf lettuce,
cherry tomatoes, carrots,
cucumber, house croutons,
balsamic vinaigrette

Wisconsin Wedge
Butter lettuce, Nueske’s
bacon, tomato, crumbled bleu,
Treat Bake Shop candied
pecans, creamy peppercorn
dressing

Caesar Salad

romaine, parmesan cheese,
house crouton, lemon wedge,
house Caesar dressing

Apple Bleu

heritage greens with petite
green and red leaf lettuce,
apple, crumbled bleu cheese,
Treat Bake Shop candied
pecans, dried cranberries,
champagne vinaigrette

Spring/Summer Panzanella
arugula, red onion, cucumber,
tomato, basil, shaved
parmesan, fresh baked bread,
creamy peppercorn dressing
(available in
Spring/Summer)

Superfruit

heritage greens with petite
green and red leaf lettuce,
strawberries, blueberries,
crumbled goat cheese,
walnuts, balsamic vinaigrette
(available in
Spring/Summer)

Peach
pea tendril greens, char grilled
peaches, burrata, Treat Bake
Shop spiced almonds, peach
balsamic dressing
(available in
Spring/Summer)

Strawberry

sunflower shoot greens,
strawberries, Treat Bake Shop
candied pecans, balsamic
bellavitano cheese,
champagne vinaigrette
(available in
Spring/Summer)

Fall/Winter Panzanella

kale greens blend, shaved
brussels sprouts, cornbread,
butternut squash, fresh herbs,
creamy peppercorn dressing
(available in Fall/Winter)

Winter Greens

kale greens blend, green
apple, shaved brussels
sprouts, carrots, pomegranate,
balsamic bellavitano cheese,
champagne vinaigrette
(available in Fall/Winter)