Party Catering Menu Drop off

Party Catering Menu | Drop Off Delivery

Farm to Table EventDrop Off means your party catering is a low profile drop off delivery. If you are looking for something with more support and staff please head to our Party Full Service Menu. Feel free to ask about our vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free menu options. Download our menu in PDF format herePlease see our FAQ for common menu and catering questions.

 

Parties are about friends and family, gathering together, hanging out, and of course food and drink. You shouldn’t be worried about the food, preparing the table, or dealing with the mess after the party! Impress your friends by using a world class party caterer. Us! We excel at servicing all types of parties in the Milwaukee area, whether a birthday, anniversary, baby shower, holiday, quinceanera, graduation, super bowl, theme parties etc. We also have special menus for Thanksgiving and Holiday Catering.

Starters

Choose from a mix of hot, cold, or trayed appetizers to get the party started.

hot

minimum order 2 dozen
pieces for each hot item

 

 

Mini Bourbon BBQ
Pork Meatballs

ground pork, house
breadcrumbs, Tall Guy
Bourbon BBQ Sauce
$15.99/dozen

 

Lamb Meatballs

ground lamb, house tzatziki sauce $13.99/dozen

 

Mini Pretzel Bite &
Brat Skewer with
Sprecher Root Beer
Mustard

Wisconsin brat and pretzel
bites, bamboo skewer,
mustard dipping sauce
$15.99/dozen

 

Rumaki

dates stuffed with cream
cheese, wrapped in Nueske’s
bacon
$15.99/dozen

 

Arancini Bites

cheesy herbed risotto, panko
crusted and fried
$15.99/dozen

 

Wisconsin Napoleon

Carr Valley bread cheese,
char grilled Wisconsin
smoked sausage, potato,
mustard vinaigrette, bamboo
skewer
$17.99/dozen

 

cold

minimum order 2 dozen
pieces for each cold item

 

Elote Tartlet

Alsum Farm sweet corn,
queso fresco, mayo, spiced
lime vinaigrette, micro
cilantro, savory tart shell
$19.99/dozen

 

Grilled Peach Skewer

char grilled peach, fresh
mozzarella, basil, Oro di
Oliva peach balsamic glaze,
bamboo skewer
$15.99/dozen

 

Creole Shrimp
Skewers

Cajun seasoned shrimp on
bamboo skewers, spicy house
remoulade
$25.99/dozen

 

Caprese Skewer

fresh mozzarella, cherry
tomatoes, and basil on
bamboo skewers with
balsamic glaze
$15.99/dozen

 

Fruit Skewers

trio of seasonal fruit on
knotted bamboo picks, glazed
with rum, lime juice, brown
sugar, and honey. can be
customized with your favorite
fruits upon request
$17.99/dozen

trays &
platters

 

Farm Stand

assorted Wisconsin cheese,
sausage, and Potters crackers.
includes soft/hard cheeses that
are seasonally available, locally
sourced salamis, house made
pickles, dates, and S.A. Braai
seasonal chutney
12” platter $69.99
16” platter $99.99

 

Veggies

colorful assortment of seasonal
raw veggies. rainbow carrots,
purple cauliflower, sliced bell
peppers, tomatoes, and
broccoli. served with ranch
dressing. small tray includes 1
pint of ranch, large tray
includes 2.
12” platter $49.99
16” platter $79.99

 

substitute Roasted Red Pepper Hummus or seasonally available Sweet Potato
Hummus for Peppercorn Ranch: $5/pint

 

Fruit

seasonal assortment of sliced
fruit.
12” platter $49.99
16” platter $79.99

 

Cold Smoked Salmon
2 to 2.5 pounds of cold
smoked Faroe Island Salmon,
grilled lemons, capers, aioli,
pickled red onions, herbed
cream cheese, sliced
flatbread, crostini
16” platter $139.99

 

Mediterranean

assortment of seasonal cold
and balsamic glazed grilled
vegetables, olives, hummus,
sliced flatbreads, and crostini.
12” platter $79.99
16” platter $99.99

 

Tenderloin Sliders

thin sliced beef tenderloin,
peppercorn horseradish sauce,
seasoned greens, served on
Miller Baking Company
pretzel slider buns
1 dozen $59.99

Pretzel Bites & Dips

Miller Baking Company
Pretzel bites with Sprecher
Root Beer Mustard, Mustard
Girl Stone Ground Deli
mustard, roasted red pepper
hummus, and Tall Guy
Pretzel dip.
Large Bowl (feeds 20 people)
$89.99

 

Chips & Guacamole

large bowl of house fried red
corn tortilla chips, 1 pint each
of tomato salsa and elote
(corn relish), and 1 quart of
fresh guacamole.
Large Bowl (feeds 15 people)
$89.99

 

Bar Snacks

large bowl of house lattice cut
potato chips, one pint of Tall
Guy chip dip, half pint of
house made pickles, small
bowl of smoky pretzels with
local mustard, one pint of
artisan nut mixture.
(feeds 20 people) $89.99

Sandwiches and Wraps

Buffet Style
Minimum order is 10 people. Our sandwich & wrap Buffet includes your choice of up to 3 unique
sandwich or wrap selections for groups of less than 20 people. For groups of 20 guests or more, up to 5
sandwich or wrap selections can be chosen. This buffet also includes a seasonal chef’s choice seasonal
salad, house made potato chips, and assorted fresh baked cookies. $14.99/person

Box Lunches
Wraps and sandwiches include house fried lattice cut potato chips, seasonal fruit side, and fresh baked
cookie. Minimum order is 10 box lunches which can consist of up to 3 different choices. $14.99/person
Orders greater than 20 can include up to 5 different box choices. To guarantee your selections,
please place your order at least 48 hours in advance. Since we prepare our food fresh to order,
ability to fill last minute requests is limited.
A La Carte sandwiches and wraps are available for $7.99/each

Cold Sandwich and Wrap

 

ITALIAN SANDWICH
smoked ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, fresh smoked
mozzarella, mayo, Full Belly giardiniera, greens, and black
olive tapenade on ciabatta bread

 

SMOKED HAM & CHEESE SANDWICH
smoked ham, house pimento cheese, sliced green apples,
and greens on ciabatta bread

 

ROAST BEEF SANDWICH
fresh sliced roast beef, crumbled Gorgonzola, balsamic
caramelized onions, peppercorn horseradish sauce,
and greens on ciabatta bread

 

TALL GUY TURKEY WRAP
all-natural turkey breast, Full Belly giardiniera, seasonal jam,
pickled red onion, greens, and sharp white cheddar cheese
on a whole wheat wrap

 

TURKEY BACON WRAP
all-natural turkey breast, sharp white cheddar, crumbled
Nueske’s Bacon, tomato, greens, peppercorn ranch
dressing,whole wheat wrap

 

CHICKEN SALAD WRAP
char grilled chicken breast, celery, dates, pecans, greens,
and seasonal chutney cream cheese spread on a whole
wheat wrap

 

PESTO CHICKEN WRAP
house basil pesto (nut free), char grilled chicken breast,
shaved parmesan, tomato, greens, whole wheat wrap

 

CHICKEN CAESAR WRAP
char grilled chicken breast, house Caesar dressing, shaved
parmesan, tomato, greens, whole wheat wrap

 

VEGGIE HUMMUS WRAP
roasted red pepper hummus spiced with artisan sriracha from
The Brinery, cucumbers, carrots, sliced bell peppers, and black
olive tapenade on a whole wheat wrap

Hot Sandwich and Wrap

 

PORTABELLA WRAP
balsamic marinated and grilled portabella mushroom, sliced
bell peppers, crumbled goat cheese, greens, roasted red
pepper sauce

 

STEAK SANDWICH
sliced steak with house steak seasoning, mushrooms, onions,
bell peppers, bleu cheese, garlic aioli, ciabatta bread

 

REUBEN SANDWICH
sliced corned beef, Swiss cheese, kraut, thousand island,
marble rye

 

ITALIAN BEEF
shaved beef, giardiniera, smoked mozzarella cheese,
ciabatta bread

 

CUBAN SANDWICH
smoked pork, ham, house pickles, Swiss cheese, mustard,
ciabatta bread

 

BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH
pulled buffalo chicken, crumbled bleu cheese,
pepperoncini peppers

Additional Options

 

POWER BOWL
heirloom rice blend topped with sweet potato, chickpeas,
tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, and house tahini vinaigrette.
also included is your choice of either sliced steak or chicken,
seasonal fresh fruit cup, and a fresh baked cookie

Hot Buffet

From tacos to bbq to Italian, we’ve got you covered. Includes earth friendly disposable place setting and serving utensils. Minimum order for any hot buffet is 10 people. We are happy to accommodate any dietary restrictions or customize any of our menu items to meet your needs. To guarantee your selections, place your order at least 48 hours in advance. Because we prepare our meals fresh-to-order, our ability to fill last-minute requests is limited.

BBQ BUFFET
$15.99/person
includes fresh baked cornbread
and honey butter, Carolina slaw,
chef’s choice seasonal salad, and fresh
baked cookies.
choose 2 of the following to complete
your BBQ buffet:
• Smoky Pulled Pork
• Sliced Smoked Beef Brisket
• Pulled Chicken
• Baby Back Ribs
• Pulled BBQ jackfruit (Vegan)

 

MARDI GRAS BUFFET
$14.99/person
a taste of New Orleans. includes
red beans and rice, Cajun braised
chicken pan sauce, chef’s choice
seasonal salad, apple cider braised
collard greens with Nueske’s bacon,
cheddar biscuits, and fresh
baked cookies.

 

ITALIAN BUFFET
$15.99/person
includes Mama Mucci’s fresh garlic
and parsley linguine, house
marinara sauce, smoked mozzarella
alfredo, Grandma Betty’s beef
meatballs, sliced grilled chicken,
Caesar salad, garlic bread, and fresh
baked cookies.

TACO BAR
$14.99/person
includes corn and flour tortillas, tomato
salsa, peach salsa, queso fresco, sour
cream, house made guacamole, chef’s
choice seasonal salad, house fried red
corn tortilla chips, and fresh
baked cookies.
choose 2 of the following to complete
your taco bar:
• Chopped Smoked Beef Brisket
• Sliced Flank Steak
• Sliced Chicken
• Smoky Pulled Pork
• Sliced Portabella with Sautéed Onions
and Peppers (Vegan)
• Pulled BBQ Jackfruit (Vegan)
add Mexican rice with cilantro lime
black beans for an additional
$2.50/person

 

MEDITERRANEAN BUFFET
$14.99/person
includes char-grilled chicken breast
topped with Mediterranean relish
(olive blend, crumbled feta, tomatoes),
roasted red potatoes, charred green
beans (fresh green beans, topped
with gremolata – parsley, lemon zest,
garlic), chef’s choice seasonal
salad with dressing on the side, rolls
and butter, and assorted fresh
baked cookies.

SLIDER BUFFET
$15.99/person
chef’s choice seasonal salad, house
potato chips, fresh baked cookies, Miller
Baking Company pretzel slider rolls,
and condiments. rolls and condiments
are packaged separately so guests can
build their own custom sliders.
choose 2 of the following entrees to
complete your slider buffet:
• Bourbon BBQ Pork Meatball
with Carolina Slaw
• Pulled BBQ Chicken
• Smoked Pulled Pork
• Smoked Beef Brisket (+$2/pp)
• Cheddar Stuffed Beef (+$2/pp)
• Ground Turkey, Feta, and Spinach
(+$2/pp)
• Maple Glazed Pork Belly with Pickled
Red Onions (+$2/pp)
• Mini Brats with Kraut
• Vegan Black Bean
• Portabella Mushroom with Mixed
Greens and Roasted Red Pepper
Sauce (Vegan) (+$2/pp)

 

MAC + CHEESE BAR
$14.99/person
penne pasta, house pimento cheese
sauce, crumbled Nueske’s bacon,
scallions, crumbled bleu cheese,
shredded Wisconsin cheeses, hot sauce,
and pickled jalapenos. includes chef’s
choice green salad and fresh baked
cookies. choose one of the following
proteins to complete your mac
and cheese bar:
• Chopped Smoked Beef Brisket
• Smoky Pulled Pork
• Sliced Beef Brisket
• Meat or Vegetarian Chili
(includes side of sour cream)
• Pulled Buffalo Chicken

Deli Salads

All items are available in small bowl (feeds 10), medium bowl (feeds 25), and large bowl (feeds 45) sizes.
Carolina Slaw • Small $19.99 • Medium $29.99 • Large $39.99
All others • Small $29.99 • Medium $59.99 • Large $89.99

CAROLINA SLAW
shredded cabbage and carrots, dressed
with apple cider vinegar and Dijon
mustard Southern style dressing

 

TALL GUY PASTA
tri-color rotini, Wisconsin cheese
curds, diced bell pepper, sliced black
olives, cherry tomatoes, house
Italian vinaigrette

 

MEDITERRANEAN PASTA
charred artichokes, olive medley,
roasted red peppers, feta, parsley,
green beans, house vinaigrette

FINGERLING POTATO
crumbled Nueske’s bacon, egg, fresh
green beans, diced celery, fresh herbs,
fingerling potatoes, house vinaigrette

 

NEW POTATO
jalapeno Caesar dressing, diced tomato,
shaved brussel sprouts

Power Bowl Buffet

$15.99/person
Minimum order is 10 people A family style version of our popular, healthy power bowls! Our power bowl buffet is a family style bowl of our heirloom rice blend topped with sweet potato, chickpeas, tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, and house tahini vinaigrette. also included is your choice of either sliced steak or chicken, chef’s choice seasonal green salad, seasonal fresh fruit salad, and fresh baked cookies.

A La Carte

mix and match some of our favorites to create your own custom buffet! half pan size feeds 8-10 guests • full pan size feeds 20-25 guests

BAKED MOSTACCIOLI
three cheese blend, house marinara, fresh Italian herbs, roasted red pepper flakes.
Half Pan $29.99
Full Pan $49.99

 

BEEF LASAGNA
locally sourced ground beef, fresh lasagna noodles, Wisconsin cheese blend, ricotta, house marinara
Half Pan $44.99
Full Pan $79.99

 

VEGETABLE LASAGNA
seasonal sautéed vegetables, ricotta cheese, fresh lasagna noodles, and smoked mozzarella cream sauce.
Half Pan $36.99
Full Pan $69.99

SLIDERS
$36/dozen
these quarter pound sliders come 12 to an order and include rolls, sliders, and condiments packaged separately.
• Bourbon BBQ Pork Meatball with Carolina Slaw
• Pulled BBQ Chicken
• Smoked Pulled Pork
• Sliced Beef Brisket
• Cheddar Stuffed Beef
• Ground Turkey, Feta, and Spinach
• Maple Glazed Pork Belly with Pickled Red Onions
• Mini Brats with Kraut
• Vegan Black Bean
• Portabella Mushroom with Mixed Greens
and Roasted Red Pepper Sauce

Salads

All items are available in small, medium, and large sizes.
Small Bowl (feeds 10) $29.99 • Medium Bowl (feeds 20) $49.99 • Large Bowl (feeds 30) $69.99

HOUSE SALADS

available to be enjoyed year round

 

GARDEN
heritage greens with petite green
and red leaf lettuce, cherry tomatoes,
carrots, cucumber, house croutons,
balsamic vinaigrette

 

WISCONSIN WEDGE
butter lettuce, Nueske’s bacon, tomato,
crumbled bleu cheese, candied pecans,
creamy peppercorn ranch dressing

 

CAESAR SALAD
romaine, parmesan cheese, house
crouton, lemon wedge, house
Caesar dressing

 

APPLE BLEU
heritage greens with petite green
and red leaf lettuce, apple, crumbled
bleu cheese, candied pecans, dried
cranberries, champagne vinaigrette

SPRING/SUMMER SALADS

seasonally available

 

PANZANELLA
arugula, red onion, cucumber, tomato,
basil, shaved parmesan, rustic croutons,
creamy peppercorn ranch dressing

 

SUPERFRUIT
heritage greens with petite green
and red leaf lettuce, strawberries,
blueberries, crumbled goat cheese,
walnuts, balsamic vinaigrette

 

PEACH
pea tendril greens, char grilled peaches,
burrata, Treat Bake Shop spiced
almonds, champagne vinaigrette

 

STRAWBERRY
sunflower shoot greens, strawberries,
candied pecans, balsamic bellavitano
cheese, champagne vinaigrette

FALL/WINTER SALADS

seasonally available

 

PANZANELLA
kale greens blend, shaved brussel
sprouts, cornbread, butternut squash,
fresh herbs, shaved parmesan, creamy
peppercorn ranch dressing

 

WINTER GREENS
kale greens blend, green apple, shaved
brussel sprouts, carrots, pomegranate,
balsamic bellavintano cheese,
champagne vinaigrette

Desserts

Choose from an assortment of our signature mini desserts (minimum
order 2 dozen pieces for each dessert unless otherwise noted)

ASSORTED HOUSE BAKED COOKIES
(minimum order is 1 dozen)
$19.99/dozen

 

MINI CHOCOLATE BROWNIES
$9.99/dozen

 

MINI CHEESECAKE TARTLETS WITH
SEASONAL BERRY TOPPING
$14.99/dozen

 

HONEY MASCARPONE
rolled chocolate tuile filled with creamy mascarpone
and Wisconsin honey
$18.99/dozen

 

MINI ITALIAN CANNOLI
$18.99/dozen

LEMON CARDAMOM RICOTTA
rolled chocolate tuile filled with fresh lemon and cardamom ricotta
$16.99/dozen

 

LEMON CURD TARTLETS WITH CANDIED LEMON ZEST
$13.99/dozen

 

ROLLED CHOCOLATE TUILE WITH CHOCOLATE MOUSSE
$16.99/dozen

 

CHOCOLATE TARTLET WITH COFFEE MOUSSE
$15.99/dozen

 

SMALL DESSERT PLATTER
35 assorted mini desserts, includes minimum of 3 different flavors
$49.99

 

LARGE DESSERT PLATTER
60 assorted mini desserts, includes minimum of 3 different flavors
$84.99