Shop Local in Milwaukee this Holiday Season

Wine and Table

Shop Local in Milwaukee this Holiday Season

Get in the #shoplocal spirit with Tall Guy and A Grill this holiday season!  You can feel a sense of pride in knowing that you’re supporting #local Milwaukee businesses when you order from our Holiday Menu.  We’re known for using locally-sourced, quality ingredients from some of the best vendors around, so your food not only tastes amazing – it tastes fresh.


Holiday Appetizers 

Kick-off the festivities with Tall Guy’s Creole Shrimp, spiced with Cajun flavors and our made-from-scratch dipping sauces.

Creole Shrimp

As for an easy appetizer that seems to please everybody, make sure to order a gourmet Wisconsin Cheese, Sausage, & Cracker Platter.  This locally-sourced platter includes: two chef’s choice salami, hard & soft crafted cheeses, assorted artisan crackers, and our homemade pickles!

Wisconsin Cheese, Sausage, & Cracker Platter

Just like the rest of our Holiday Menu, these starters pair beautifully with a Villa Maria Sauvingion Blanc & Stemmari Nero D’Avola.  You can find these delicious wines at Ray’s Wine & Spirits.


Holiday Side Dishes 

All soup, salads, and side dishes are made from scratch and packaged in oven-safe pans to serve 8 to 10 guests (unless otherwise noted).

Butternut Squash Soup

Your friends & family will love the taste of our house made Butternut Squash Soup, made with locally-sourced apples, sage, and a touch of Wisconsin maple syrup.  It’s a great first-course.

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

We’ve also got you covered with traditional favorites, like: Garlic Mashed Potatoes, Sweet Potato Casserole with Treat Bake Shop Candied Pecan Streusel, Green Bean Almondine, and Roasted Red Potatoes with fresh herbs.  

Roasted Red Potatoes

Your side options don’t end there!  Here’s a full menu listing so you can mix & match your favorites.


Holiday Main Course 

As for the main course, our juicy Beef Tenderloin comes with a choice of peppercorn horseradish sauce, beef gravy, or au jus.  You’ll also see Rosemary & Apple Roasted Pork Tenderloin on the menu this year.  This new creation happens to be a favorite of Executive Chef Dana Spandet.

holiday pork tenderloin

  Our Holiday Menu also features seasonal classics, like: an all natural, boneless Turkey Breast, maple ginger glazed Hickory Ham, Wisconsin grass-fed Beef Lasagna, vegetarian options, and so on.

Beef Lasagna

Whichever entrée you choose for your party, I can promise you this: it will taste just as good as it looks.

Hickory Ham


Holiday Catering Made Easy 

Per usual, we can cater your Milwaukee holiday party onsite – OR – you can simply scroll through our Holiday Menu and personalize your order online for pick-up.  We’re also available to chat over the phone (414-777-0770) to share personal menu favorites, answer any questions, and make sure your party – of any size – is treated to an amazing holiday feast.

cheers with dan and amanda

We’re here to make the holidays as simple as possible for you, all while feeling good about supporting local Milwaukee businesses (like me!).

Happy Holidays

Tall Guy owner dan nowak

I’m the owner of Tall Guy. A 2016 AList Finalist for the Best Wedding Caterer. Our passion for great food inspires us to create exceptional dishes using the highest quality and locally sourced ingredients. Contact us today to service your event!